A Digitel opinion: Why tablets and technology matter in the world of publishing
For all the advances of desktop and laptop computers over the years, the computer medium remains a very active user-driven experience for readers.
A user will type in keywords and grab a mouse to select individual stories based on brief synopsis of the material. An observer from the 70s would likely compare the experience more towards using a database than reading a magazine.
This transformation of print into something more akin to a database has caused newspapers and magazines to suffer greatly online. The online experience (while more timely and offering a much increased diversity of content) simply isn't as enjoyable as a magazine experience.
And, maybe, if we learned this lesson today we might not have to wait to see many of the benefits promised by the tablet age.
And that's why the rise of the next generation of tablet computers is so important. (Note: I'm not talking about Kindles, but devices that have no keyboard, a full-color screen, a long battery life, and are compact and lightweight and designed to be controlled direct by a human hand on a touch screen.)
Tablets offer the promise of recreating the magazine experience of easy-to turn pages, designs that reflect the importance of content, and advertising placements that adjust with the days content and designer's choice of display. That is: You can have the best of the magazine experience with some of the searching and real-time nature benefits of computers and the Web.
This promise could easily be destroyed by publishers that might (and many will) simply offer their Web site on this next generation of devices and call it a day. Doing this would change nothing, it perhaps could even degrade the experience further by requiring human hands to manipulate content designed for keyboards and mouse pointers.
But if publishers can find a way to blend the near-real-time nature and content-rich environment of the Web with the well-designed and simple user experience of magazines, real progress may well be made in recreating a lost experience.
This video by Bonnier Research & Development is one of the better dissections of reader experiences on tablet devices that I've seen.
Now if the concern of poorly executing tablet design wasn't enough to strip these devices of a silver bullet status, then the reality of how long it will take readers to buy them surely will.
Even if all publishers could create a fantastic user experience, it will be at least several months before these devices come to market and many months and years until there's an appreciable number of users using them.
The point is that advanced tablet computing could be the dawn of a glorious new day for publishers, but only for those that are willing to step back and begin to understand how the nature of a device dictates the user experience.
And, maybe, if we learned this lesson today we might not have to wait to see many of the benefits promised by the tablet age.
If we began to properly treat the Web as a tool that was designed for timely information updates, readers would have better experiences online. And the shorter more bereft articles placed online will drive more readers to print and forthcoming tablet publications.
Technology offers many benefits but it is only a problem for those that use it without first understanding it.
Comment and read more
our topic pages and automatically found related coverage.
Brian Wilder
12 Jan 2010 5:23 pm.
oooh! Is this like a staff ed.?
We should do more of these...
19 Jan 2010 5:39 am.
Oh good.. another new gadget.
As far as I can work out, the point made here is that browsing the web does not have the enjoyable experience of flicking through a magazine and so a new electronic device is offered to make digital browsing more 'magazine-like'.
This does beg for the obvious question of 'why not just actually flick through an actual magazine.. actually?', but then, people are not doing that as much anymore, which is the crisis facing publishing.
The Tablet may contribute to the evolution of media consumption technology but I think any device made specifically for a purpose like this will be soon outdated. People don't want lots of different devices to perform lots of different functions. They want one device that performs ALL the functions and provides all the services available. Apple have already demonstrated this with the success of the iPhone.
What designers should be thinking about is a device like the iPhone that ALSO offers 'magazine-like' digital experiences.
Personally, I'd rather read a magazine or a book.
Ken Hawkins
19 Jan 2010 6:52 am.
Right. That's why I've always felt kindle style devices have limited lifespan.
But if I can have a tablet that's great for casual Web browsing (which is how most Web consumption is done anymore) and it's great for reading magazines, even better.
Basically, I'd suggest that the tablet becomes the core computing device in a decade pushing out laptops -- much like laptops are pushing out desktops.
I'd agree the physical medium is nice, but there's a whole host of negatives from cost to environmental to time that are killing it.
Timmons Pettigrew
19 Jan 2010 10:16 am.
Magazines are fun and tactile, but with the exception of comic books I'm not going to pay for something in print I can get for free or much cheaper online. For the most part, I'm after content, not the tactile experience. I generationally missed the boat on newspapers so that's an obviously one to me, I'll never pay for a newspaper. Magazines I'll pay for only if I'm traveling beacuse I can't get online on a plane...but if I could, I wouldn't buy them.
I've got a soft spot for the tactile, cinematic experience of a comic book though, that I can't get from reading one one a computer screen. But, again, that's because I grew up loving them. There will be subsections of folks with the same dedication to newspapers or magazines, but will there be enough to sustain whole publishing industries? Long term, probably not. This is why I pay $2.99 for a comic book, and $3.99 for a great one from an independent publisher like Avatar.
Timmons Pettigrew
19 Jan 2010 11:33 pm.
Interestingly enough, my favorite living writer on the planet, Warren Ellis, posted a piece today semi-related to this. He's been harping on about Print-On-Demand services for some weeks.
http://www.warrenellis.com/?cat=46